Home | Twitter | Facebook | Ask DMI | The CU Soapbox | Click.Connect.Communicate. | Exigent911.com

Receive Posts by Email

View Our Twitter Feed

  • Blog Cloud
  • RSS Dodd-Frank Tracker
  • Sign Up for the RSS feed

    Visit Our Contact Us Page

    Categories

  • 20andChange
  • Aite Group
  • Banks
  • Blogging
  • Budget Stretching Ideas
  • Can't Miss Reading List
  • Collections
  • Compliance
  • coupon
  • Coupons
  • Credit
  • Credit Cards
  • Credit Union News
  • Credit Union Tech
  • Credit Unions
  • crisis communication
  • CU Soapbox
  • customer service
  • deficit
  • Depression
  • DigitalMailer
  • DigitalMailer 10th anniversary
  • Do You Want Fries with That
  • Dodd-Frank
  • e-mail
  • e-Statements
  • economy
  • electronic statements
  • email
  • email marketing
  • emergency
  • enrollment campaigns
  • eStrategy
  • Facebook
  • Financial Crisis
  • Financial News
  • Financial Scams
  • Finovate
  • FinovateFall 2012
  • Generation-Y Marketing
  • give-aways
  • Great Ideas from CUs Like Yours
  • green
  • green technology
  • Groupon
  • Heartland Systems
  • Hurricane Ike
  • Hurricane Ike Texas
  • Interchange
  • junk mail
  • Lauren's Corner
  • Loans
  • Marketing
  • marketing on a budget
  • member enrollment
  • mobile technology
  • Money
  • My Virtual StrongBox
  • NARFE Premier
  • NetPromoter
  • NPS
  • Old Hickory Credit Union
  • On-Boarding
  • One Click
  • One Click Campaign
  • post office
  • postal service
  • Predatory Lending
  • Promoter
  • Reg E
  • ROI
  • Ron Rants
  • security
  • Seminars
  • Shell Federal Credit Union
  • smart marketing
  • smart phone
  • snow
  • Social media
  • SPAM
  • spam filters
  • SPAM history.
  • Special Reports
  • Survey
  • Surveys
  • targeted marketing
  • TDECU
  • technology
  • Texas Credit Unions
  • Texas CU
  • The Better Mouse Trap
  • Twitter
  • Uncategorized
  • weather emergency
  • web sites
  • Webinars
  • The DigitalMailer Blog

    August 16, 2012

    How do you “measure up”?


    A great article just came out of MarketingProfs.com, offering up new insights into the average open rates, click-through rates (CTRs), and unsubscribe rates for financial service email marketing campaigns. To highlight a few important points:

    • Financial services campaigns had a 22.6% average open rate. This might seem small, but it’s actually pretty good compared to other businesses (especially education, health and retail). If you’re getting open rates higher than 22%, you’re doing well.
    • FIs can anticipate an average CTR of 3.5%. Again; small in theory, big in practice. You always want this number to be higher than it is, and the more focused your list, the more you should expect a high CTR.
    • The average unsubscribe rate for FIs is .18%. What?! You read that correctly – that’s point-one-eight percent. It might make you think that people really love getting emails from their FI, yes? Not necessarily. See, that doesn’t account for people who see an email from their bank or credit union and drop it into trash. Nor does it account for “priority inboxing” (thanks, Gmail, for making emails even harder to get read).

    So, what can we take away from all this? Well, as an industry, it would be nice if those rates reflected a highly-engaged readership. It can happen, it DOES happen. But we also shouldn’t use this to shame ourselves out of ever using email marketing again — remember, these numbers are actually pretty good, considering.

    How can we raise the bar?

    • Better Content/Unique Content – The short-and-sweet way to increase your open rates? Make sure it’s an email worth opening. Consider special offers that are only accessible via your email list. That way, users aren’t just users, they’re “insiders”.
    • A Better Focus on Calls-to-Action – As we’ve discussed before, try out different calls-to-action – text, images, text AND images, different wordings, different positions – it all matters, and it’s all dependent.
    • The “Let-Out” – Don’t hide unsubscribe links from people. If they want out, let them out. It’s only going to improve your open rate in the long-run (after all, the open rate is the number of opens divided the number of emails sent – decrease the bottom number and the percentage will increase. Simple math, yes?)

    Learn more about DigitalMailer’s Email Marketing engine, the ARB.

    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    September 30, 2008

    The History of SPAM: The Mail That Wouldn’t Die!


    by Jimmy Marks (with Greg Crandell)

    Part 1 of our long awaited “SPAM Series” is a horror story (just in time for the start of October…we’re all excited about Halloween over here). Jeffry Pilcher, E-I-C of the blog The Financial Brand, sent me a story (and seven or eight actual examples) of e-mail gone wrong.

    What follows is the story of…”THE MAIL THAT WOULDN’T DIE!”

    I never signed up for email notifications from Jupiter Images, a stock photo supplier. Nevertheless, I started getting email from them. Too much, too little relevance. So…

    April 29 – I try using the unsubscribe option in the email. It bounces back.

    April 30 – I send an email directly to the sender of the spam (rare that there was an actual, real reply-to address). I told him I no longer was in a position to buy stock photos, so “please remove me from your mailing list.”

    May 22 – I’m still getting spam, so I try the unsubscribe option again. No dice.

    May 22 – I send this message to sales@jupiterimages.com: “I should be able to unsubscribe. I believe Jupiter’s non-functioning unsubscribe email address is in violation of the anti-spam laws. Please fix this. Thanks.”

    May 29 – The sales rep sending out spam says he’s trying to take care of this for me. He wants to know if I want to be completely removed from every email list they have. I tell him “yes.”

    June 3 – Still getting spam. Try unsubscribing again. Nope. Send emails begging: “Unsubscribe me pleassseeeee.”

    June 5 – More spam. I’m f**king pissed now. Blood boiling. I go online and Google as many Jupiter email addresses I can find, then send the following message to 26 employees of the company: “Sorry, I don’t want to be a jerk, but nothing else has worked and I’m out of options… I’ve tried THREE TIMES to unsubscribe from your mailing list, but YOUR UNSUBSCRIBE EMAIL ADDRESS HAS BEEN DISABLED, which, by the way, IS ILLEGAL. ILLEGAL! My patience has expired. An “unsubscribe” process that should have taken 3 seconds has now taken seven emails (make that 8, with this one) over the span of a month. A MONTH???? EIGHT EMAILS??? This is unacceptable. I’ve highlighted the most-relevant excerpts from this process in my messages below. I think everyone can agree that this would push even the most patient and understanding person past the breaking point. Your company will IMMEDIATELY find a way to stop sending me emails. IMMEDIATELY. NOW. Thank you —in advance— for your swift and effective response. P.S. – I don’t want any more emails. Period. That includes apologies or explanations. I don’t want to see another email from Jupiter EVER. Just take me off your list. All of them.”

    June 6-15 – Despite my request to the contrary, I get emails from these folks apologizing and promising to do whatever they can to remedy the situation. “Eff you… just do it,” I’m thinking.

    July 24 – Yep, you guessed it. BINGO! Another promotional spam email. This time, the message was short and to the point: “You have got to be kidding me… One more email from you and I’m calling a lawyer. Got it? – jp”

    July 25 – The sales guy figures out the only way he can stop email from getting to me is to go in and change my email address. He can’t delete it. He can’t change its settings. All he can do is garble up the address so that it bounces back.

    Future – If I get another email, I’ll spend up to $5,000 of my own money on a lawyer.

    Frightening, yes? It’s all too common. From Greg:

    The CAN-SPAM Act uses broad language. Where Jeffry says he didn’t sign up for e-mails is an example of this, as businesses are allowed to dispatch e-mails to clients/patrons without a prompt. But Jeffry was facing a problem that’s fairly common – it’s not that the people sending you the automated e-mail don’t provide a solution, it’s that the solution doesn’t work.

    In thinking more and more about SPAM, I realized a fundamental truth: SPAM is in the eye of the beholder. Jeffry didn’t want his e-mail about pictures just like anyone else might not want chain e-mails about the Arctic Fox or the Presidential Campaign. In either case, they’re a grievance, but it’s the simple fact that you’re getting a whole lot of what you DON’T want that makes it so aggravating.

    Special thanks to Jeffry for sharing his indignation with us.

    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    September 10, 2008

    The History of SPAM: An Introduction


    In the next few weeks, Greg Crandell will shed light on the origins of SPAM – how it came to be, how it continues, and how you can avoid it on both ends of the e-mail spectrum.

    Before we here at DigitalMailer begin this long and winding road to understanding SPAM, we want to hear from you. How has SPAM affected your personal life, your e-mail, the way you do business online, your marketing efforts, or your world in general?

    If you have questions, comments, stories, photos, screenshots, videos, recordings…whatever… that has to do with SPAM, send it to us at this address. We want to hear from you.

    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------